CAC Payback by Cohort: How Graymatter Knows It Pays Off | Checked Out Ep 9

Live Podcast
Minimalist calendar icon with two rings on top and a horizontal line in the center representing a date or event.

October 30, 2026

Dark purple right-facing play button icon with rounded edges and hollow center.

48

Min

Key Takeaways

  • Let data overrule the founder. Jim Phillips, founder and CEO of Graymatter, runs the team on "data over ego": ads he expected to crush did nothing, and ads he thought looked terrible did well, so performance data gets the final say.
  • Track acquisition cost and cohort contribution margin together. Jim watches new customer acquisition cost by channel and contribution margin by monthly cohort, so he knows by month two or three when a cohort breaks even and starts making money.
  • Protect your subscription offer, even if you build the tool yourself. About 95% of Graymatter buyers subscribe. When resellers used the intro offer to resell on Amazon at full price and win the buy box, the team built its own blocker, The Warden, in a matter of days with AI.

Featured speakers:

Jim Phillips

Jim Phillips

Founder & CEO 
Graymatter

Shannon O'Boyle

Shannon O'Boyle

Head of Marketing 
Relay Commerce

Harry Willis

Harry Willis

 
Smartrr / Relo

Will Jones

Will Jones

Co-founder 
SavedBy

Partners:

Relay
live podcast

Last Friday of Every Month.

11am EST | 4pm GMT.
Check it Out

Inside the show

Three lifelong partnerships people turned coworkers decided to start a podcast. Tune in for unfiltered conversations where they let off steam and talk shop with surprise guests from the Shopify ecosystem.

Jim Phillips

Jim Phillips

Black and white envelope icon symbolizing email or messaging.

Shannon O'Boyle

Shannon O'Boyle

Hoster of themed parties, master of ceremonies, washed-up D1 walk-on, startup marketer, and mom of 2.

Black and white envelope icon symbolizing email or messaging.

Harry Willis

Harry Willis

Music nerd, purple belt in Brazillian Jiu Jitsu and black belt in subscription commerce. Professional Zoom caller and sender of emails.

Black and white envelope icon symbolizing email or messaging.

Will Jones

Will Jones

Black and white envelope icon symbolizing email or messaging.

Surprise guest

Silhouette of a person’s head and shoulders with a large question mark inside the head area, symbolizing an unknown or surprise guest.
from the Shopify ecosystem.
Revealed Live.

RSVP

A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.A solid purple circle with a slightly darker purple border.